Guys & Dolls:
- Large Ensemble Musical Production
- Set Design (Mike Hesser)
- Actor in a Leading Role (Kent Coffel as Nathan Detroit)
- Actress in a Leading Role (Stephanie Merritt as Miss Adelaide)
- Actor in a Featured Role (John Jauss as Nicely-Nicely Johnson)
- Actor in a Supporting Role (Larry Love as Benny Southstreet)
- Actor in a Non-Singing Role (Robbie Haupt as Harry the Horse)
The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas:
- Large Ensemble Musical Production
- Choreography (Kimberly Klick)
- Lighting Design (John Jauss)
- Actress in a Leading Role (Tina Poynter-Abell as Miss Mona Stangley)
- Actress in a Supporting Role (Leigh Edmonston as Ruby Rae/Dogette/Angelette)
- Actress in a Supporting Role (Caitlin Perlow as Angel)
- Actress in a Supporting Role (Lynda Waters as Jewell)
- Actor in a Cameo Role (Thommy Crain as The Governor)
- Actor in a Cameo Role (Kevin J. Jones as Band Leader)
- Actor in a Cameo Role (Pat Klick as Farmer/Dogette/Aggie Solo)
- Actress in a Cameo Role (Kimberly Still as Doatsey Mae)
- Actor in a Non-Singing Role (Reggie Pierre as CJ Scruggs/Aggie)
- Actor in a Non-Singing Role (Zachary Stefaniak as Sen. Wingwoah/Dogette)
- Actress in a Non-Singing Role (Chris Beckner as Miss Wulla Jean/Edsel Mackey)
Winners will be announced at Arts For Life's 13th Annual Best Performance Awards event on June 10, 2012.